I'm getting married October 2010, and my FH and I are really wanting to go St. Lucia through Sandals resort. But seeing as how you don't want to go anywhere tropical, maybe consider going to New Hampshire. I think it's the most beautiful place to go in the Fall ~ the mountains, the trees *sigh* lol. We actually went this past September for NASCAR (hate the sport, but that's a whole other story lol). But I absolutely loved just being there. We're going again this coming September. There's not much to do as far as crazy exciting things, but because it's your honeymoon, renting a cabin by lake would be sooo romantic. New Hampshire is more of a toristy, site-seeing, shopping kinda town. I know they have a ship that you can go on and it takes maybe a 3 hour ride on the water. Or they have a long train ride as well - giving you a chance to view everything beautiful in New Hampshire.